The GSTN has addressed practical issues faced by taxpayers while filing appeals where adjudication orders reflect NIL demand due to prior voluntary payment during the show cause notice (SCN) stage.

Key Clarification

Tax authorities have clarified that:

• Payment made during the SCN stage is often to avoid interest or penalty escalation

  Need help with this? Talk to Goyal Raj Kumar & Associates →

• Such payment does not amount to acceptance of liability

• Taxpayers retain the right to appeal under Section 107 of the CGST Act, 2017

This ensures that procedural actions do not restrict substantive legal rights.

Practical Issue Faced on GST Portal

Taxpayers encountered challenges where:

• The GST portal restricted filing of appeals in NIL demand cases

• System validations did not allow appeal filing without a demand amount

  Need help with this? Talk to Goyal Raj Kumar & Associates →

Resolution Provided

GSTN has now enabled a mechanism allowing:

• Filing of appeals even where final demand is NIL

• Proper selection of appeal category and grounds

• Recognition of taxpayer rights despite prior payment

Why This Matters

• Protects taxpayer’s legal right to dispute tax liability

• Reduces unnecessary litigation on procedural grounds

• Ensures fair interpretation of voluntary payments

Legal Backing

• Section 107 of the CGST Act, 2017 (Appeals)

• Section 73 & 74 of the CGST Act (SCN provisions)

• Relevant GSTN advisory/clarification on appeal filing

Conclusion

This clarification brings much-needed relief by confirming that voluntary compliance does not waive the right to challenge tax positions.

For expert guidance on this topic, contact your tax professional today.